On the value of ownership
Hands up anyone who knows someone who buys books because of the way they can compliment a room? Leatherbound or classic Penguin, definitely old and from a worthy writer, the checklist is easy to compile. They add dignity to the space they inhabit and weight to the owner. Buying them and displaying them, perhaps on shelves or perhaps in carefully arranged stacks, is a declaration of taste as the owner looks to impress upon us a holistic approach to interior design.
Many of us shrink from such displays even if we also display our books in such a way. Ours, for starters, have all been read, all loved and bought for the right reasons. We don’t buy art to match the curtains and we don’t buy books to rest between carved, wooden bookends.
But we do like it when others notice our more natural display of bookish taste. That old copy of Oliver Twist was bought second hand and read on holiday. That’s genuine. Dickens is a genius and still relevant today. And yes, we now buy hardback books, special editions where available, signed if possible – not because they look good to others but because they add to the pleasure of reading.
Because there is nothing wrong with collecting.
What is it about owning things that brings such pleasure? We all make our decisions, draw our lines in the sand when it comes to ownership. For some a “serious” book must be real but quick reads could probably be digital. For others all books could be digital but take away our LPs and there will be a ruckus. The pleasure is in the decaying paper, the smell, the scratchy sounds of the stylus, the ritual of purchase and consumption; things come into focus like stars aligning with our self-image.
Is the value, therefore, of a product in the core offering (the words, the ideas) or is it something entirely different, larger? Is it in the way it is wrapped up and presented? Is it in the kudos it bestows upon us? Why do we pay more for nicer packaging and to what level will this be replicated on digital devices? Much space is given over to the “dvd extras” approach but do they add any real value for the customer? Would, in short, the same consumer who might have bought into a physical special edition be persuaded to pay an extra few pounds for some behind the scenes video extras or author journals? Is physical design worth more than digital design?
Look at the chatter surrounding pricing on the iPad vs that of the iPhone. The standard of games on the latter impressed everyone and has shaken the world of gaming. Fully featured games for less than a fiver. Yet when it comes to the iPad people are wondering what is justifying the extra cost. Is screen size enough to charge more and if not how do we really know whether the game has been improved on the iPad?
It’s all a magnificent, personal and rambling subject of course. But as the road to digital downloads becomes as assured as the road to hell, it’s a subject worth considering.